Search results for query: *

Forum search Google search

  1. PC : Partial German victory in ww1 ?

    Is the collapse of Germany's allies inevitable at this point? To what extent can Germany redeploy their Eastern Front troops to shore up Austria-Hungary and/or the Ottoman Empire (if possible). I don't know enough about the situation but it seems to me their fates would dictate how long...

  2. Thoughts on consequences of a total Polish defeat in the Soviet war of 1920

    I am inclined to agree, namely, the most Germany would dare in this context would be the Polish Corridor. Germany might be able to co-ordinate, to an extent, with the USSR for de-facto recognition of this in exchange for not contesting Soviet intrusion into the Baltic States. On the other hand...

  3. Thoughts on consequences of a total Polish defeat in the Soviet war of 1920

    Would this scenario alter the fates of the Baltic States, Finland and (less likely) Turkey? If we assume, which seems the consensus, that Poland will be a separate Communist Republic, will this also be imposed on these other countries or will the USSR settle for guarantees of neutrality?

  4. A Better (Luckier) Napoleonic Peace (Avoid 19th century Franco-Prussian War + 20th century World Wars)

    The idea of a southern (or Catholic) Germany is appealing as a counter to Prussia and eventually Germany. But I agree the Habsburgs are unlikely to be successful in administering it given their weaknesses in managing their own empire. Is there any prospect of Bavaria being given this role? Not...

  5. What if Pompey was not assassinated?

    I suspect Pompey's fate might be similar to Lepidus'. In effect, given a sinecure and left in peace but clearly kept away from any real power. But like Lalli I am not altogether sure whether Pompey's pride would accept such a role - he might also be influenced by the ambitions of his son's, who...

  6. Chamberlain dies, September 16th 1938

    Is Leo Amery a possibility?

  7. Why was public opinion so up in arms over Italy conquering Abyssinia, why was Hoare-Laval Pact so scandalous?

    This is a good question, particularly given Britain and France's imperial holdings. I've always wondered (admittedly with no evidence) whether there was a sophisticated German propaganda campaign of some kind to sway public opinion to create such friction. It was a tremendous boon to Nazi...

  8. Perhaps one day, but not in the immediate future. One thing I have learned is that the next...

    Perhaps one day, but not in the immediate future. One thing I have learned is that the next story I write will already be finished before I post it - I have too many unfinished TLs on this board. Once again, thanks for your comment.

  9. Thanks for your comment. I appreciate the interest on this TL. Unfortunately, I've lost the...

    Thanks for your comment. I appreciate the interest on this TL. Unfortunately, I've lost the motivation to write the story anymore. There have been brief fits of inspiration, but it has never caught fire. I hesitate to say I have totally abandoned it because I actually plotted out the main...

  10. AHC: Deist majority/plurality in America by 1900

    I'm not an expert but I think this is right. Prior to the US constitution, many states had legislation barring Catholics from public office unless they took an oath not to support the Pope. Even after the constitution there were many instances of anti-catholic bigotry, though discrimination in...

  11. AHC: Deist majority/plurality in America by 1900

    Perhaps if the various Christian churches attempt to politically intervene in the American war of independence in a ham-fisted way? For example, fearing a precedent being set by European empires falling to 'natives', the churches preach that independence is fundamentally immoral and try to...

  12. Out of wheelchair. I have been recovered for some time now, but shortly after surgery I started...

    Out of wheelchair. I have been recovered for some time now, but shortly after surgery I started an acting appointment as Chief of Staff to a high-profile position. So, extremely busy. That acting appointment finished today, so hopefully I can catch up on the story this weekend.

  13. Is it possible for Europe to keep its colonies and grant the natives equality?

    The only places it would work is with colonies that have small populations. These ideas were floated by most of the empires at one time or another, but inevitably racism kicks in and all sorts of excuses come to the front as to why it can't be implemented. The stark truth is that colonial powers...

  14. Italy changes sides in 1942

    Interesting question. I agree the Allies are not going to agree to any Italian conquests post 1945. Even the retention of Libya will likely come with some conditions. Not sure on how the rest of the war plays out, but Italian politics after the war will be interesting. The fascists are...

  15. Hi.

    Hi.

  16. WW1? Size of BEF to deter Germany

    I hope this is a simple question. Historically, the WW1 peacetime BEF was approximately six infantry divisions and one cavalry division that would be deployed to the continent (France) in the event of war. Presumably the Imperial German Army, in their planning for the invasion of France through...

  17. Other cases of countries being partitioned?

    Yugoslavia? Split between a northern communist state and a royalist Serbian state? Also, IIRC there were proposals for the partition of Austria too. Hopefully I don't remember that just from a TL.

  18. AHC: A British Version of Eisenhower/De Gaulle

    As a highly competent friend of mine once said after he was approached to run in a safe seat, most people are too smart to enter politics. Especially in this era of the 24 hr news cycle. I suspect many generals would feel the same, especially if they have to start at the bottom again. However...

  19. WI: The powers of ww1 had today's weaponry

    Turkey I grant, but with modern borders Japan is in no danger. But the scenario has already ruled out modern borders, so there will be a Far East theatre.

  20. WI: The powers of ww1 had today's weaponry

    Assuming modern borders and no empires, all continents except Europe will win.
Top