WI: Greater popularity of penal colonies?

So what if the penal colonies had a greater level of popularity by the various colonial powers of the 19th Century? With the various great powers sending criminals and their families to their overseas colonies in the same vain has Britain and Australia.

Examples:
  • Spanish to the Philippines and Cuba.
  • Germans to Deustch East Africa and southwest Africa.
  • French to French North Africa and Indochina.
  • Portuguese to Angola and Mozambique.
  • Belgians to the Congo.
 
Last edited:
Sending Germans to New Guinea or the Bismarck Archipelago would probably end up like Devil's Island in French Guiana. The place would be a graveyard for convicts and being transported there would be akin to a death sentence.

Speaking of the Pacific, the French preferred New Caledonia as their penal colony in addition to Devil's Island.
 
Namibia would make more sense as a German penal colony. There's not much economic incentive to send a bunch of convicts halfway around the world just to have them all die of malaria.
 
Sending Germans to New Guinea or the Bismarck Archipelago would probably end up like Devil's Island in French Guiana. The place would be a graveyard for convicts and being transported there would be akin to a death sentence.

Speaking of the Pacific, the French preferred New Caledonia as their penal colony in addition to Devil's Island.

Namibia would make more sense as a German penal colony. There's not much economic incentive to send a bunch of convicts halfway around the world just to have them all die of malaria.
Fair enough I'll change it.

So what would be the best places for more Penal colonies and what would be the long term implications of the penal colonies?
 
IOTL, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands were a penal colony for Indian rebels. Presumably, if Britain retained Bengkulu, that could be a penal colony for Indians as well.
 
Beginning in the 15th century, prisoners called degredados (exiles) were utilised by the Portuguese to settle the Atlantic Islands (Cape Verde and São Tomé and Príncipe particularly) along with the enclaves in what is today Morocco. In the 16th century, Brazil became a major destination, with Salvador being founded by 600 degredados in 1549. The fortresses in Sub-Saharan Africa relied mostly on degredados to man and defend them. Angola became particularly important with prisoners coming not just from Portugal, but from Brazil and other colonies. Many made their way inland and established themselves as traders, particularly in the slave trade. Foreign prisoners were also taken to Angola, as in 1820 when an agreement between Portugal and the Two Sicilies, saw Angola take in Sicilian prisoners.

Angola remained a penal colony until the 20th century, though political prisoners were sent to Tarrafal on the island of Santiago in Cape Verde between 1936 and 1974. Below is an article on Angola's degredados.

https://locus.ufjf.emnuvens.com.br/locus/article/download/2537/1814
 
Last edited:
Russia settled Siberia with its criminals and religious and political dissenters.

Other potential exemples would be Libya for Italy, the Dutch East Indies for the Netherlands and the Rio de Oro for Spain.
 
This is well outside colonial times, but the Achaemenid Empire used Bactria as a penal colony for rebellious Greeks.
 
The United States has had so many good locations for a federal penal colony during its history.

Wyoming and Montana would probably be the best until the full scope of Alaska's resources are known. But any government willing to do this is probably some sort of totalitarian United States (probably a USSA). Prison labour has always been a thing, but I just can't see people willing to expand it that far. I suppose all federal prisons could be located in Montana, Wyoming, and Alaska, with the government using federal prisoners for exclusively convict labour. I suppose the state prisons in those places would be used for the same.

The problem is incarceration was generally a state issue for most of the United States's history, so you'd suddenly need to change that through laws I can't imagine the government passing outside of something like a USSA.

So how would it effect the demographics of these regions in the long run?

Well, French Guiana is 14% white, a higher proportion than neighbouring Suriname or Guyana. New Caledonia is 27% white, unlike the rest of Melanesia. And a great example of demographic change via penal colonies is the Kolyma region which became intensely populated thanks to the gulags, although of course the main reason people "chose" to stay after their release from the gulags was the government forcing them to stay.
 
Spain used various colonies to send its colonies, often sending convicts to fortified settlements called presidios. In 1787, Ceuta had a population of 7,076 of whom 2,365 were presidiarios or prisoners. That same year Oran and Mazalquivir had 7,764 with 2,214 being presidiarios. An estimated 26,000 Spaniards were shipped to Oran during the period of Spanish rule, The practice of sending convicts to North Africa continued until 1911. Estimates suggest that Spain sent some 80,000 convicts to North Africa between 1550 to 1911.

Spaniards were also sent to the New World, with some 25,000 making their way to serve in New Spain between 1550 and 1811, often being settled in the frontier regions of New Spain. Additionally, some 4,000 Spaniards were sent to the Antilles to serve out their sentences between 1769 and 1837. Most were shipped to Havana and from there distributed to different parts of Cuba along with Puerto Rico, New Orleans, and Pensacola. Until 1817, much larger numbers of prisoners were shipped from Spanish America, particularly from New Spain to the Philippines and Marianas. In the latter years these were often insurgents from the independence wars shipped from Acapulco or San Blas across the Pacific.

During the late 19th century several thousand prisoners from Cuba, Puerto Rico and the Philippines were also sent to Fernando Poo, these were usually political prisoners.
 
Namibia would make more sense as a German penal colony. There's not much economic incentive to send a bunch of convicts halfway around the world just to have them all die of malaria.
If there is a way for a penal colonies to actually turn a profit, they will become extremely popular.
Well if I remember correctly Namibia was rich in diamonds and various precious metals. So that would one way for them to turn a profit and would also provide an incentive for them to stay.
 
Top