Disaster Averted (Titanic Lives)

Night of Near Tragedy (1912)
RMS Titanic Alternate History Title Card 2v.2.png
April 14, 1912
The weather was becoming more frigid, causing breath to appear as mist as the crew and passengers alike braced themselves for another cold evening as a part of the last couple days on their journey. As the sun descended into the sea and stars took its place, passengers alike made their way within the ship's warm interiors to stay warm and enjoy one another's company. The Titanic’s crew however would be forced to stay awake and on duty for the night as the ship approached the dark abyss.

At 9:00 PM, Captain Smith returned from a party hosted in first class on his behalf in Titanic’s A La Carte Restaurant, and reached the bridge where Second Officer Charles Lightoller was on duty as the ship sailed into the night. Neither man spoke for a time, as each continued to look out into the darkness beyond the glass windows of the bridge towards the unknown. Despite the close call previously with the American Ocean Liner SS City of New York in which the Titanic had nearly drawn in the smaller vassal due to the ships massive propellers, the voyage had gone on without an issue and the ship was making good time.

For Captain Smith, this voyage would be he's last before retirement, after serving roughly a decade from 1880 when he was but a young sailor first entering into a career at sea, to now. Serving in peace time and during war, as well as on board countless ships of the White Star Line (including the sister too Titanic, RMS Olympic) now would be his final send off.
Captain Edward Smith (1912) first Captain of the RMS Titanic
Second Officer Charles Lightoller
Within the bridge, Captain Smith and Second Officer Lightoller remained quiet for a time, admiring the calm oceans ahead and lack of wind in the air.

“No wind or heavy seas, sir.” Lightoller said, breaking the silence.

“And only a degree above freezing as well.” The Second Officer continued, glancing briefly at the Captain who listened quietly.

“This sea will keep us from sighting the water breaking off any ice. However, the weather is clear.”

A quiet hum was the only reply, as the captain remained before turning to leave but not before saying; “Maintain speed and heading, Mr. Lightholler. At the first sign of a haze of ice, reduce speed.”

"Yes Sir."

Leaving finally, Lightoller remained on duty as the Captain retreated into the chartroom just behind the bridge. As the ship continued to cut through the Atlantic sea ahead, gradually a chill began to descend across the ships decks as evening began to arrive in full force, blanketing the sky in a sea of black with the only light provided by stars.

Stepping inside the chartroom, 4th Officer Joseph Boxall greeted the captain as the latter entered. “Evening, sir.” Captain Smith replied with a ‘evening,’ of his own before locating a table showcasing the course of the RMS Titanic on a map of the Atlantic Ocean. The route was highlighted with a pencil, leading from Southampton and all the way across to the ships final destination of New York.
4th Officer Boxall

Fourth Officer Boxall spoke up, “She is making good time, sir. In a mere two days or less, we will be arriving in the morning of April 16.” "Mhm," the Captain then talked with Officer Boxall for a briefly before heading off to his cabin. Despite seeming ready to head off to bed, the Captain instead was intending to return to the bridge on occasion and check in from time to time.

As Sixth officer Moody arrived at the bridge, a cup of tea in one hand and dressed in a thick jacket for the cold, Lightholler addressed him. “Call up the crows nest, and tell them to keep a sharp lookout for ice, especially small ice and growlers.”
6th Officer Boxall

Moody nodded as his reply, before using the telephone behind the helm to deliver the message. At the other end of the line, the lookouts picked up, and Moody relayed; “Be on the lookout for ice, small and growlers!”

Close by to the bridge and chartroom, within the Marconi Wireless room, Senior Wireless Operator Jack Phillips and his partner, junior Wireless Operator Harold Bride, worked all day and into the night delivering messages on behalf of Titanic's passengers to Cape Race, a wireless station located at Cape Race, Newfoundland, Canada.
Jack Phillips
Harold Bride

Irritable and annoyed from having to stay up and constantly work around the clock, Phillips completed yet another message when he picked up one sent by the ship, Mesaba, warning of an ice field. “Ice report. In lat. 42 N. to 41.25 N.long.49 W. to long. 50.30 W.
Saw much heavy pack ice and [a] great number [of] large icebergs, also field ice. Weather good, clear.”

Sighing in contempt, Phillips was tempted to ignore the message but instead sighed before quickly writing it down as a message for the bridge as he turned to his mate, Bride, and awoke him from his sleep. “Ay, got another ice warning. Take it up to the bridge, will ya?” Deeply annoyed at having his rest interrupted, Bride begrudged his partner and got up before snatching the message from Phillips hand. “Bother these ice warnings…” The man then quickly put on a coat before leaving up to the bridge.

As 10:00 PM had already arrived, Lightoller was finally able to leave the watch as First Officer William Murdoch arrived to take his place. Blowing into his hands, Murdoch tried to warm them from the freezing cold air that now enveloped him as he stood at the helm. Just minutes after taking the watch, a shivering and annoyed Bride walked into view as he held out the letter, clearly eager to go back to bed and get under the warm sheets.
First Officer William Murdoch

“Ice warning, sir.” He quickly left before Murdoch could reply, leaving the man alone to look at the contents of the message. Reading them to himself, Murdoch squinted his eyes as he processed the information in his mind before deciding to act. Next thing he knew, he reached for the engine order telegraph and pulled the lever back then forward as its bells rang. “Slow ahead.”

Down below, Titanic’s chief Engineer, Joseph Bell, heard the sound of the bells ring behind him. Checking the telegraph, Bell quickly turned to a fellow officer before calling out the orders to the engine crew. "Ahead Slow!" Another man carried the order and shouted it out as Bell replied back to the bridge as he moved the lever on the telegraph indicating he received the order.
Behind the bridge, within the navigation room, Captain Smith and 4th Officer Boxall discussed the ship's current course and speed until Murdoch arrived. “Sir, Ice warning.” The Captain, turning to face the first officer, immediately reached for and received the ice warning in his hand. Looking it over, he then looked up at Murdoch. “Did you reduce speed?”

“Yes sir. She has slowed, and I immediately came to you.” Nodding, Smith turned to Boxall and addressed the man. “Be on standby.” to which the man replied back, “Yes sir!”

After the two men left to the bridge, Boxall remained briefly before gathering himself before venturing out into the cold and frigid boat deck. At around 10:30 PM, Lightollar arrived at the bridge to check in as he went about his rounds, spotting the Captain and Murduch together in deep discussion. Lightollar spoke up, “Evening again sir.”

“Evening Officer Lightoller.” The Captain had gotten serious, as the second officer noticed, his eyes landing on the Ice warning in the captain’s hands. “Ice ahead sir?” The Captain nodded slowly, “Pack Ice. We can’t see under these conditions, thus we may have to stop for the night.” The Captain then turned to the first Officer Murdoch. “Prepare to ‘all stop,’ on my command,” “Yes sir!” before he turned to Lightoller and finished with; “have the lifeboats at the ready incase of an emergency.” “Yes sir!”

The two men left to fulfill their duties as the Captain walked into the chart room once again, this time plotting Titanic’s new course and actions for the night.

Around the time of 11:07 PM, Phillips had yet another message come in, one which unfortunately rang loud due to the proximity from the ship and the sender (Californian) which was but a few miles away. “MGY MWL. I say, old man. We are stopped and surrounded by ice.” Now beyond furious with having been interrupted in the midst of yet another message, Phillips replied back. “Quit it! I am busy! I am working Cape Race!”

Hearing this, Californian’s operated merely sighed and considered heading off to bed, before simply opting to grab a warm drink before returning to duty.
At 11:30 PM, lookout Frederick Fleet spots a black mass on the horizon, gradually exiting the darkness beyond. “There’s Ice ahead!” he shouts as his fellow lookout, Reginald Lee, watches in astonishment as the iceberg slowly appears. Ringing the bell three times, the sound echoed across the deck as the deck crew, who were already in the early stages in preparing the lifeboats, halted their actions and looked forward towards the bow.

Murdoch, alongside Captain Smith, looks ahead on Titanic’s bridge wing and sees the burg slowly appear. “Hard to starboard!”

As Murdoch quickly turned and ran into the bridge, the Captain followed as the telephone rang behind them which Officer Moody picked up. “Is anyone there!?”

“Yes, what do you see?” replied Moody,

“Iceberg right ahead!”

“Thank you!”

Quartermaster, Robert Hichens, at the wheel immediately begins to turn as quickly as he can. Murdoch then hears Captain Smith issue the next order, “Engines, all STOP!!!” Murdoch quickly moved on ahead and grabbed hold of the levers of the engine telegraph order and brought them to all stop.

Down below, in the deeper parts of the ship where the boilers where steam was created to power the ship, Lead Stoker Frederick Barrett located in Boiler Room N.6 spots the light indicating the all stop illuminate. “Shut the Dampers!”

Loud clunks rang out as the firemen raced to shut the furnaces and stop shoveling coal, an action repeated with the rest of the boiler rooms towards the front and back of the ship.

As he gets off the phone, Fleet notices the bow slowly begin to turn away from the burg, the leviathan now much closer. It wasn’t enough as Titanic’s side reached the burg and scraped alongside. As Ice falls onto the well deck, a vibration was felt throughout the ship as the crew on the boat deck watch in astonishment as the mountain of ice appears to sail past them, nearly coming into contact with the forward lifeboats, before disappearing into the night.

Down below, the forward cargo holds and boiler room six were suddenly breached as water began pouring from the side as the ship's hull plates opened up like a zipper to the sea. In the aftermath, Frederick Barrett would report seeing the damage; “Two feet above the stokehold plate.” As he and the rest of the fire stokers flee either through the use of ladders or the room connecting to Boiler Room 5.
Mere seconds into the impact, the Captain turned and shouted out “Hard to Port!” To which, Hichens quickly began to turn the wheel as Murduch rushed into the wheelhouse and activating Titanic’s watertight doors. At 11:40 PM, the collision was written into Titanic’s log book. Boxall arrived on the bridge as Captain Smith and Officer Murduch quickly discussed the events which transpired.

Moving to the starboard bridge wing, the three looked out towards the stern of the ship and saw the iceberg gradually disappear. Looking down towards the waterline, scrap marks are left in the icebergs' wake, but no other signs of damage are seen.

Boxall quickly leaves to check for damage, as Quartermaster Oliver arrives to which the Captain ordered him to; “Find the carpenter.” Second Officer Lightoller, who had been on the boat deck ordering about the deck crew to prep the lifeboats, returned along with Third Officer Herbert Pitman (the latter who had been awoken by the collision) and the two men spoke briefly. “What’s happened?” Pitman had asked, having been forced to wake up feeling a vibration throughout the ship. Lightoller replied back, serious. “An Iceberg. Prepare to be called up by the Captain.”

Pitman, stunned for a moment, nodded before returning to his Cabin and getting properly dressed whilst Lightoller took a look down the ship's port side then returned to his own cabin. After noticing the ship is not listing to one side, ordered the ship to move ahead and set the telegraphs to slow.

Finally however, the ship begins to list over from her port side to starboard, as the ship previously had a three degrees list due to large amounts of coal on the opposite side of the collision due to a coal bunker fire previously. Alfred Oliver, a seaman who had previously been at the wheel, arrived before receiving a letter from Smith addressed to Chief Engineer Joseph Bell.

It was sometime after the Captain and a couple officers had gone off to inspect the damage caused by the collision. Boxhall, having arrived at the mailroom located above the cargo holds, noticed the clerks desperately attempting to move the mail up and away from rushing water to which the Officer tries to retrieve one such floating bag but fails. Boxhall instead returned to the bridge, as during this time Thomas Andrews, Titanic’s Chief designer, was quick to walk down the grand staircase and pass by passengers who stopped and watched silently, leaving behind his cabin on A-Deck.

Noticing the tense atmosphere, Andrews stops briefly and looks at some passengers before saying; “Even if Titanic were split in three sections, each would still be able to float.” With that, he left as the Captain arrived back on the bridge after his own inspection was done. Issuing yet another order for all hands on deck, Chief Officer Wilde (who had gone to inspect the forward most compartment and learned it wasn’t flooding) had now arrived with Officer Murdoch and Second Officer Lightoller on the bridge.

“Are all Lifeboats prepped and ready?” The Captain said, serious now as Lightoller nodded his head slowly. “Yes sir, all of which are nearly prepped and ready to be swinged out at your command.” The Captain nodded, before turning to address the two other Officers present. “First Officer Murdouch, you will take charge of the lifeboats on the port side. Chief Officer Wilde, you will manage the lifeboats on the starboard side.” “Yes sir!” Both replied before leaving to the boat deck.

“Chief Pursor McElroy,” the named man listened carefully to he’s captains next words, “Muster the passengers up and have them be ready to abandon ship.” “Yes sir!” The man replied before he left to fulfill his duties and gather the passengers onto the upper decks.
Lightoller, the only officer present, then asks. “Should we begin lowering away?” The captain shook his head, before turning to look out the bridge wing once more. “Not until we learn the full extent of the damage.” The Captain paused before looking to Lightoller, “Aide First Officer Murdoch on preparing the lifeboats, Mr. Lightollar.” The Officer saluted before leaving the bridge, and Captain, alone.

Boxhall arrived just as Lightoller left, and quickly told the Captain his findings. “The mail room has begun flooding sir, that likely means the forward Cargo holds have been breached.” Nodding his head, Captain Smith and Boxhall were quickly joined by Pitman who had finally gotten dressed and came out on deck, being directed to the bridge by Lightoller. “Sir?”

Looking to Pitman, Smith’s eyes wearily turned back to Boxhall before he gave out his next orders. “Aide Chief Officer Wilde and First and Second Officer Lightoller in preparing the lifeboats and ushering passengers on deck. Be mindful of what you say to them about what is happening to avoid a panic.” Deciding to leave the bridge, the Captain had just completed a walk down a second flight of stairs when his eyes caught sight of Thomas Andrews. “Mr. Andrews!” The man stopped and turned, spotting the captain approach.

“What’s happened?” The Ships designer asked, already dreading the potential answer. Smith, taking a moment to collect himself, replied back- “We’ve struck a burg on the port side, and are taking on water. So far, in the mail room, thus likely we are taking in water in the cargo holds of the compartments just before Boiler Room 6.”

As first class Stewardess, Annie Robinson, comes out and begins making her way out of her room, she overhears the two men talk between themselves with the phrase; “There’s three gone already.” As Officer Pitman moved to check for damage, he came across some firemen from down below. The men looked exhausted and spent as they met the Officer on the forward welldeck, seeming to have been in a desperate sprint to flee. “What’s happened?”

One of the men spoke, breathless and struggling for air, “6 *breath* boiler room sir! She’s taking *breath* on water!” Shocked, Pitman and the men moved to check the forward cargo hatch, only to see water flooding the cargo holds. Leaving quickly, Pitman rushed back up to the boat deck, revealing the news to his fellow officers upon his arrival.

Within the Marconi Wireless room, Junior Wireless Operator Harold Bride had been awoken by sounds of shouts and men moving around on deck, whilst his partner Jack Phillips was in the midst of working on sending out another message. Just as Bride was going to ask what the commotion was all about, the Captain entered the room. “Be on standby to send out a distress call. I will return to give the order.” The two men froze and watched in astonishment as the Captain left them there dumbfounded by what they heard.

As passengers gathered together in the reception room, they spotted Thomas Andrews as he quickly made his way by and up the grand staircase. Some try to ask questions or get his attention. “Mr Andrews? What’s happening? Mr. Andrews!” But he ignores them, focusing on reaching the boat deck, taking three steps at a time, before reaching the bridge. There, meeting with the Captain, Andrew delivers the news. “Titanic is sinking by the head, four of her watertight compartments have begun to flood.”

The Captain nodded, signaling for Andrews to continue. “The water will nearly reach E-Deck, by which time we risk them nearly spilling over into the next compartments. She will hold but the danger is still there, Captain.” “I see.” The Captain replies, before turning to leave and heads to the Marconi Wireless room once more.

Immediately upon his arrival, Jack Phillips and Harold Bride both await their orders as the Captain opens the door to the room. “Begin sending out a distress call and alert any ships nearby of our situation as quickly as possible.” As like before, Captain Smith turned and left the room as the two men got to work in sending out distress calls to any nearby ships in the area.

As 5th Officer Harold Lowe stepped out onto the deck, he spotted several passengers wearing lifebelts. This instantly caused him to move and help the crew in completing getting the lifeboats ready, as Chief Officer Wilde ordered the windows on the Promenade Deck opened to allow Passengers to climb out and onto the lowering lifeboats. As this is happening, Officer Boxhall is alerted by a crewman and a few stop to look towards the horizon as a light appears. Seeing this, Boxhall quickly moved to the bridge and spoke with the Captain as he watched the lifeboats be prepped and passengers be brought out into the cold air on deck.

“A light on the horizon, sir!” Boxhall said, as the two men looked towards it. “Should I send a distress signal?” “I have done so already,” the Captain replied back. “Our position you used?” “Our position was taken at 8 o'clock.” Releasing the position was much fathered then what the Captain gave, Boxhall quickly left to update the ships current position.

Before Boxhall left, he turned to the Captain once more. “How serious is the danger?” Captain Smith paused briefly, considering his words before replying. “She is on a knife's edge, Mr. Boxhall. She will float, but we mustn't take any chances. Mr Andrews tells me he gives her an hour to an hour and a half if she begins to flood past the fourth compartment before the 6th Boiler Room.” Quickling arriving at the Bridge, the Captain and Officer turned to face Harold Bride as he approached. “SS Californian has heard our distress calls and is attempting to make full steam for us, sir.” The Captain felt the relief wash over, as Officer Boxhall turned and left the Bridge. “Have any other ships responded? Yes sir, RMS Carpathia is making full steam and will be here in four hours.”

“Thank you.” The Captain spoke as Harold left, whilst out on Deck, Officer Pitman met with the chairman of the White Star Line, J. Bruse Ismay. “Why aren’t the lifeboats being filled?” “We haven’t been given the order to.” The two men watched as more and more passengers arrived up on deck, quickly crowding around them. “The evacuation should start immediately.” The Chairman replied, looking back at the Officer. Pitman nodded, “I shall ask the Captain,” before he turned and left to find him.

After confirmation, lifeboats begin to be filled on port side and begin to lower as passengers reluctantly get onboard them. As Boxhall moved to try and signal the ship on the horizon, the Captain and Chief Officer Wilde observed the evacuation in progress. As Murcdoch watched lifeboat 7 leave, he called down to the crew below. “Bring her around to the gangway door to take on more passengers!”

As Lifeboat 4 on the starboard side lowered, the Captain ordered for passengers to be loaded by the promenade deck. Nearby, other lifeboats were prepped and loaded and began to be lowered away. With lifeboat 5, Pittman helps passengers alongside William Murduch, where nearby a panicking Bruce Ismay watches on. Once the lifeboat is filled to near capacity, Pittman and Murduch shake hands before the former takes command of the lifeboat which begins to be lowered.

Just as the lifeboat is lowered, Ismay struggles to breath before grabbing hold of one of the davits. “Lower away! Lower away! Lower away!” Clearly reaching his breaking point, the chairman is interrupted by a frustrated, Officer Lowe promptly pulled him away before putting him in he's place.

Throughout the evening, and into the early morning hours, the crew worked around the clock to try and keep the ship afloat whilst also evacuating passengers from the stricken ship. By around 2:17 am of April the 15, 1912, Collapsible lifeboats A & B were lowered away, about 1059 passengers remained on the ship as she remained low in the water by the bow.

As daybreak came and the sun gradually appeared overhead, the crew and passengers of the stricken ship came across the sight of what seemed like a sea of icebergs, drifting about from all directions near the boats and the ship herself. As Titanic remained afloat, her crew worked down below to keep the water at bay within the ship's sixth watertight compartment.

By around 2:45 a.m. RMS Carpathia had reached the edge of the icefield which Titanic found herself in, and at 4:00 a.m. had reached Titanic herself. Alongside the SS Californian, which had previously stopped the night before due to the large amount of ice which surrounded the ship, the two ships each took on as many passengers as either vessel could take with life boats from the trio continuing to move back and forth between the ships as the crews of either vessel helped the now disembarked passengers from the stricken ship. By the end of the morning hours and leading into 1:00 PM, all of the cold and frightened, yet grateful, passengers were aboard either vessel and the two ships set off towards New York City, arriving on the evening of Thursday 18 April, 1912 under heavy rain caused by a heavy thunderstorm and fog that delayed their journey. During this journey to the States, the two ships would be joined by the sister to the RMS Titanic, the Olympic which was among several vessels that had steamed for Titanic as it let out distress calls throughout the night of April 15. Her arrival in New York caused slightly confusion for many, who believed the ship to be Titanic just a day or so late.

Titanic remained, with her crew, the latter of which worked throughout the day to maintain the ship as she slowly made her way on the remainder of her journey at reduced speed to prevent an influx of water towards Halifax, Nova Scotia with the steamer SS Prinz Friedrich Wilhelm. The USS Chester, having originally escorted SS Californian and Carpathia to new York, arrived to aide Titanic when the ship limped into Halifax where a extensive effort was made to help remove the water and keep her afloat long enough for the return trip to Harland and Wolf shipyards, in Great Britain after a stop over in the United States to finish repairs. Upon her arrival, the ship alongside her crew were held as heroes alongside that of the Californian and Carpathia with many being awarded multiple medals by the Titanic's passengers for their efforts in a successful rescue and saving the ship.

Crew were awarded bronze medals, officers silver, and Captain’s Smith, Rostron (Carpathia) and Stanley Lord (Californian) each were given a silver cup and gold medal by Margaret Molly Brown. Smith and Rostron were later knighted by King George V and became guests of honor by President William Howard Taft at the White House, where the three received a Congressional Gold Medal.
 

Attachments

  • 5b6b20dbecc4c9e2b4e43bee9871ba02-3493411332.jpg
    5b6b20dbecc4c9e2b4e43bee9871ba02-3493411332.jpg
    404.3 KB · Views: 671
  • RMS Titanic Alternate History Title Card resize.png
    RMS Titanic Alternate History Title Card resize.png
    472.5 KB · Views: 38
Last edited:
Mistake Made
I did not mean to post this thread this early, I was going to work on this for longer but instead I pressed enter intending to type under some text and here we are.
I will try and flush this out with time still.

Old Message
 
Last edited:
Aftermath Photograph, circa 1912
WHITE STARLINE SHIP RMS TITANIC STRIKES ICEBURG
ON MAIDAN VOYAGE

RMS Titanic (Disaster Averted) 2.png

Photograph of the RMS Titanic as she limped in for the last stretch of her journey to Halifax, Nova Scotia. This photo would be in countless newspapers, and be one of the most famous photographs of a ship in history. Titanic leans towards the bow, due to extensive flooding of the ships forward four watertight compartments, just behind Titanic's forward most, and right up to Boiler Room 6. Throughout the attempt to rescue the ship, much of the crew remained to try and save her as they struggled along at just about 14 knots in order to not risk water being forced into the ships damaged hull.
1912_Titanic_itinerary_atlantic_EN.png

The Incident would be used in the press to showcase the apparent "Unsinkability" of the golden trio, despite such a word not being outright used; this coupled with the RMS Olympics' previous incident with the British Cruiser, HMS Hawke, would convince much of the world and especially the people of Britain that the safety of ships at sea was a assured thing. This thought process would thus remain with the British Board of Trade regulations standing, that would later reveal their short comings in the worst maritime disaster in recent memory.

In total, roughly 20 souls were lost mostly among the ships crew down below in the boiler rooms whilst trying to keep the ship afloat despite all the odds stacked against them. A memorial would be held as the 20 men would be buried with honors back in the United Kingdom with a fund set up on behalf of the families of the deceased. Titanic would remain in drydock for the next 2 months, under extensive repairs which delayed the launch of her sister ship, the RMS Britannic. She returned to service in July, 1912, beginning her second voyage under a new captain and complete her journey without issue.

Some would question what might have occurred had the RMS Titanic not survive her collision and sank that April night, on the 15th, 1912 and the consequences that would follow suite?​
 
Last edited:
You did a wonderful job writing out the dialogue and action during the collision! I could easily follow what was happening. Looking forward to more.
 
Good take on this popular subject, but there is no way any passengers would be left onboard Titanic. Carpathia, Californian, plus any other ship that made it to the site would take everyone or would stay alongside in case Titanic sank to get the rest.

If Titanic was still floating in the AM there is also the chance Olympic would make it to her sister and take a lot of the passengers.

Mostly likely Titanic would make for Halifax not NYC as it was much closer, esp in such a delicate shape. Her passengers however packed they are into which ever ship(s) may goto NYC.

Also you mention the ship moving ahead slow after the collision, except given the Officers know there is an huge ice field there ITTL then they would just stop, due to risk, which would slow water ingress.

Likelihood is a damaged ship would be patched up in Halifax, then visit an American yard for a fuller repair before risking another Atlantic crossing.

Chances are this incident will actually see a lot of boasting about ‘look how strong our ships are’ rather than getting lifeboats for all, ice patrol, and the structural changes to ship design than we got OTL which leads to many more problems later.
 
Good take on this popular subject, but there is no way any passengers would be left onboard Titanic. Carpathia, Californian, plus any other ship that made it to the site would take everyone or would stay alongside in case Titanic sank to get the rest.

If Titanic was still floating in the AM there is also the chance Olympic would make it to her sister and take a lot of the passengers.

Mostly likely Titanic would make for Halifax not NYC as it was much closer, esp in such a delicate shape. Her passengers however packed they are into which ever ship(s) may goto NYC.

Also you mention the ship moving ahead slow after the collision, except given the Officers know there is an huge ice field there ITTL then they would just stop, due to risk, which would slow water ingress.

Likelihood is a damaged ship would be patched up in Halifax, then visit an American yard for a fuller repair before risking another Atlantic crossing.

Chances are this incident will actually see a lot of boasting about ‘look how strong our ships are’ rather than getting lifeboats for all, ice patrol, and the structural changes to ship design than we got OTL which leads to many more problems later.
I thought it was reasonable idea at the time, but you are right. I figured though, considering Carpathia was the sole ship to come rescue the passengers in OTL, that in this one just her and Californian would be enough and would likely refuse any sorta help. This was more short sighted on my end, plus I wasn't quite finished with this scenario when I accidentally posted when it wasn't ready.
I wasn't sure where Titanic would go, as I had planned to look into which dockyards/harbors would be near enough for the ship to go to which is why it's so vague here, as I was still trying to come up with the finer details.
Yes, the ship moving ahead through the remaining icefield, whilst certainly unlikely to happen, I figured to just "hand wave" this aside and assume the ship had managed to make its way through slowly, bypassing the number of icebergs and entering into more open and clear sea. A huge jump I know, but that was what my thought was. Again, I was still working on this but- Well you know already.
I did consider the possibility of some sorta inquiry into this incident and just how it transpired. I figured, given the status of the ship and those onboard, the scale of this incident would at least warrant a look through and lead to some minor changes, but you also have a point there.
I'll try to make the changes with time before I continue forward with this, so feel free to comment whenever you please and let me know. I do appreciate the corrections and information.
 
To be fair, looking at the incident through a modern safety lens doesn't reflect the reality of the time. Back then, huge prestige was given to fast passage times, and for a liner with the rep of the titanic, management and ownership interests would certainly desire a record time be set on the maiden voyage.
 
There might have been the desire to get to New York in a time faster than Olympic’s, but Titanic was not going to go for a surprise Tuesday night arrival or similar; docks have to be readied, tugs booked, cabs laid on etc, plus they would want their new liner to be seen on Wed AM in daylight.
 
The Designer, Owner, and Captain
The Designer, Owner, and Captain
Thomas_Andrews_ül.jpg

Despite looking over the plans for what seemed like the 100th time, Andrews was still coming to terms with the close call with disaster that had befallen one of he's ships. The RMS Titanic, the second ship of a new breed of Ocean-Liners built by Harland and Wolf, owned by the White Star Line, was currently down by the head and going for desperate and temporary repairs to keep the ship afloat for a more extensive repair work in the states. He had been hounded by the press once word got back of what happened to the ship, and he had to be escorted by police alongside Captain Smith and J. Bruce Ismay to temporary lodging for their brief stay in Halifax, Nova Scotia. It was honestly remarkable how well he's ship had held up, despite suffering such severe damage and at constant risk of her water tight compartments failing and sending her to the bottom, she had held firm and made it by the skin of her teeth.

He should've been proud off course, but truly, Thomas Andrew's was thankful to be alive along with most of the crew and passengers. The loss of life though, no matter how minor, was still a blow to the man. 20 men died keeping Titanic afloat, deep below in the belly of the ship as water came pouring in. Their sacrifice alongside the hard work of the stokers and rest of the crew had ensured an even worse tragedy did not befall the Titanic. The press had already run stories on what happened, claiming such fantastical claims and using headlines such as; "Titanic slices through burg, no lives lost" or "White Starline Ship survives head on Collision with burg, survives and reaching Canada." It wasn't to far off, but also was not accurate either. But that was something to worry over much later.

For now, Andrews checked the time on his pocket watch before noticing it was already early morning. Placing down a pencil as he stood up from his chair at he's desk, he glanced one last time at the ship plans he had brought along and had been using to asses what the damage was done and what repairs were needed for Titanic. She was meant to survive a head on collision, strikes on the side, a tear at her bottom and even losing three watertight compartments. Yet she had survived one more then that due to an Iceberg strike. What if she had lost five or god forbade, six? She would no doubt be at the bottom.

But no, she had lived. She had been struck and yet kept afloat. Titanic was still here, thanks to the design and hard work that Andrews along with thousands of workers, designers and crew alike had done to ensure she remained afloat. Andrew's gave pause as he recalled hearing about a novel written back in 1828 named Futility: The Wreck of the Titan. Whilst Andrew's was not one to believe in prophecies or predictions, the similarities he had found had certainly caused a shiver to run down his spine. Especially given just how close Titanic came to end up like Titan.

J.-Bruce-Ismay-119980576.jpg

For one J. Bruce Ismay, the last couple of days had been a whirlwind of happenings, including dealing with the press, the loss of profit from a now ruined voyage, and near loss of the latest ship built for the White Starline. Titanic had survived, defying expectations, and made it to Halifax, Nova Scotia with four compartments filled and a fifth at constant risk of flooding. From what her designer, Thomas Andrews, had told him Titanic had prevailed against some rather unforeseen damage and made it. This off course would serve the press well and convince the world just how safe the ship, along with the Olympic-class and white Starline in general, were some of the most safest vassals to sail the Atlantic.

Not that Ismay himself hadn't assume the worse was to come, as the full weight of what was happening had brought him to his lowest, only the words of Officer Lowe had managed to snap him back to some form of composure as Titanic's lifeboats lowered away. He had eventually begun helping as many passengers as possible, either finding lifeboats not filled to capacity, directing 3rd class through the endless hallways of the ship, keeping morale up by telling the passengers the ship was coming to help, and handing out lifejackets... Ismay had been busy all night and into the next day.

It was stressful, so when all Titanic's passengers had finally been moved off the ship, Ismay considered following after them in order to get to New York and possibly hop on the next ship heading back to Britain, but he's exhaustion plus the likely fallout from this incident convinced him to stay onboard and oversee the final leg of the journey, plus deal with any legal trouble that may arise.

Now Ismay was left alone in, tired from a day of sailing and fearing he's ship may sink from under him, he was now on land and basking in the warmth of a fire place a cup of tea in hand. Ismay gently placed the cup down and watched closely as the flames danced away in the fireplace, their embers slowly rising up and disappearing from sight.

Edward_J._Smith.jpg

Wearily, Captain Smith stepped inside the room that would temporarily serve as his residence for the time being whilst he's ship was being repaired for a more extensive repairs in the states. Having been constantly at work all day and night ensuring the passengers had been safely taken off the ship, and later ensuring the ship itself was kept afloat and able to reach the relative safety of port, he had little time to just sit and rest his worn muscles.

But it had paid off. Titanic was afloat and her passengers were safe. And to think, how close he and his ship were with disaster, he dare not question the good fortune that had just befallen himself and crew. That Iceberg had gotten close to putting an end to the ship, and likely half her total compliment of passengers and crew, when they had scrapped by it.

Regardless, Smith prepared to turn in for the night and finally allow himself to rest. Tomorrow would bring about enough challenges already, and he would need every ounce of sleep he could achieve to ensure he'd be able to oversee Titanic's final journey to the states for more extensive repairs. Then, finally, he could retire at last after serving much of his life at sea.​
 
Last edited:
Nice chapter looking at some of the main players there.

To be clear, Carpathia and Californian picked up the passengers and headed for New York, only to transfer them again to the Olympic before getting there?

Whilst I am sure many would want to be on the larger ship due to overcrowding I wonder how many would want another transfer by boat in mid Atlantic?

I could see Olympic getting to the site before the rescue ships set off and taking some of the passengers, esp from Californian who was a small ship.

Hummm... not sure what I would do with this. Heh, all threee ships can be heroes, taking those who wants to transfer again and getting them to NYC.

Wonder how much symhpathy and money will be raised, esp for 3rd class passengers since they will be turning up in NYC without their luggage?
 
Nice chapter looking at some of the main players there.

To be clear, Carpathia and Californian picked up the passengers and headed for New York, only to transfer them again to the Olympic before getting there?

Whilst I am sure many would want to be on the larger ship due to overcrowding I wonder how many would want another transfer by boat in mid Atlantic?

I could see Olympic getting to the site before the rescue ships set off and taking some of the passengers, esp from Californian who was a small ship.

Hummm... not sure what I would do with this. Heh, all threee ships can be heroes, taking those who wants to transfer again and getting them to NYC.

Wonder how much symhpathy and money will be raised, esp for 3rd class passengers since they will be turning up in NYC without their luggage?
Yeah I should've given that part more thought... Recently I had watched a scenario where Olympic came to Titanic's rescue (being much closer then OTL) which inspired this version of events, but I changed that to just the Olympic continuing on her journey as before after originally heading to Titanic to help, however like the OTL, she just wasn't close enough and instead continued on her normal voyage as before.

I also reasoned, in my mind, that with Titanic's passengers shared, even between Carpathia and Californian, it would be a tight fit and thus it would be reasonable for the passengers to be shuffled around if Olympic was present. Ultimately, as to not complicate this scenario, Californian and Carpathia simply took Titanic's passengers to New York on there own.

As for who gets to be heroes, Californian and Carpathia get that, but praise is also given to Titanic's crew for their efforts alongside.
As for the loss of personal property, I will likely cover that next as I flesh out the aftermath and consequences of Titanic's survival in this universe.
 
Good take on this popular subject, but there is no way any passengers would be left onboard Titanic. Carpathia, Californian, plus any other ship that made it to the site would take everyone or would stay alongside in case Titanic sank to get the rest.

If Titanic was still floating in the AM there is also the chance Olympic would make it to her sister and take a lot of the passengers.

Mostly likely Titanic would make for Halifax not NYC as it was much closer, esp in such a delicate shape. Her passengers however packed they are into which ever ship(s) may goto NYC.

Also you mention the ship moving ahead slow after the collision, except given the Officers know there is an huge ice field there ITTL then they would just stop, due to risk, which would slow water ingress.

Likelihood is a damaged ship would be patched up in Halifax, then visit an American yard for a fuller repair before risking another Atlantic crossing.

Chances are this incident will actually see a lot of boasting about ‘look how strong our ships are’ rather than getting lifeboats for all, ice patrol, and the structural changes to ship design than we got OTL which leads to many more problems later.
You still might get the Ice Patrol. It would as OTL let ships know where ice was and to divert course. Plus those Ice Patrol ships provides a ready rescue ship and communication relay.
 
You still might get the Ice Patrol. It would as OTL let ships know where ice was and to divert course. Plus those Ice Patrol ships provides a ready rescue ship and communication relay.
It might be possible. Depends on who pays for it.

24 hour radio operation with the operators employed by the shipping line is more likely I think.

Internal second skins and better bulkheads are likely too.

Lifeboats for all isn’t cos Titanic’s lifeboats did exactly what they where expected: ferried passengers to waiting ships for rescue. Though ‘for all’ could still be argued as if Titanic had gone down the loss of life would have been huge- depends on the conservative forces at play in the various Boards of Trade there.
 
It might be possible. Depends on who pays for it.

24 hour radio operation with the operators employed by the shipping line is more likely I think.

Internal second skins and better bulkheads are likely too.

Lifeboats for all isn’t cos Titanic’s lifeboats did exactly what they where expected: ferried passengers to waiting ships for rescue. Though ‘for all’ could still be argued as if Titanic had gone down the loss of life would have been huge- depends on the conservative forces at play in the various Boards of Trade there.
For most of it's OTL life the United States has paid for the Ice Patrol,the USCG being the prime provider of ships, supplemented by the UK. I see no change in that. The changes to radio policy and ship construction will also happen as OTL, The prime mover being g Mr. Andrews.
 
Inquiry on A Wounded Titan
The morning of April 20, 1912, was a quiet morning as a light drizzle fell from the skies and a cold breeze blew over the deck crews as they worked to secure Titanic’s lifeboats in place. Behind them, black smoke rose from her tall funnels into the air, contrasting with the dark clouds overhead as her boilers warmed up and steam began filling the ships equipment once more. “Let’s take her to sea, Mr. Lightoller.” Captain Smith, who had returned to his ship that same day, looked ahead on her right bridge wing as the final preparations were made and a pair of tugboats prepared to help guide the leviathan out of Halifax, Nova Scotia for a last trip to the states whereby she would make port and begin repairs.

“Yes sir.” Lightoller turned and entered the bridge, announcing the Captain’s wishes as First Officer Murdoch moved alongside to pull the levers of the ships engine telegraphs backwards, then forwards, locking on slow ahead. Down below, men moved to shovel coal into the burning fire of Titanic’s boilers, the sound of shovels scraping the floor as they picked up piles of coal off the ground and tossed them into the furnace. Sweat pooled down the men’s faces, leaving streaks across the coal dust that covered their skin.

Up closer to the bow, crew worked frantically to ensure the ship was watertight and prepared for the open ocean once more. It had taken a long time to clear much of the water, yet still there was much left and work needed to be done in repairing the ships sides. Despite sailing at a reduced speed, her wounds had gradually grown and let more water in that compounded the flooding and risked her going under more and more. For now, the temporary repairs would hold, but no one would feel truly secure until she had been brought into drydock and made seaworthy once again.

Within the ship's vast engine room, the crews worked to start the ships reciprocating engines which spun her two outer propeller blades and began to slowly move the ship forward once more. Slowly she went, as onlookers marveled at the sight of this wounded titan as she got up to steam and began leaving her brief sanctuary and headed off to an unknown fate. Small tugs worked, pushing and pulling the massive ship until she was safely out of the harbor and in deep water. With a grateful salute from her Captain, Smith turned on his heel and returned to the bridge as Titanic made her way for the short trip to the United States. Behind him, Titanic let out a bellow from her ship's whistle that blew loud and proud into the sky.

As Titanic made her trip to Norfolk, Virginia, debates began almost immediately on how to proceed and what was learned from Titanic’s incident with the iceberg. In the states, once word reached the press had gone on to print stories based on accounts provided by the passengers and crew of both RMS Carpathia and California. The successful rescue of, at least for a time, the largest ship in the world alongside her passengers was newsworthy to many publishers, eager to let the wider world know. Newspaper boys could be seen at street corners, holding signs with such words in bold like; “RMS TITANIC SURVIVES ICEBERG STRIKE” or “WHITE STARLINER SUCCESSFUL RESCUE.” As people eagerly purchased the papers, people became hooked on wanting to learn more.
Crew of the RMS Titanic
William Randolph Hearst
Amongst them, one William Randoph Hearst, was especially interested in the story of Titanic, printing the first addition of papers on the Titanic incident as “Miracle in the Atlantic.” Not only was the story easily big for a time, but it also served as a chance to deal with one of the men Hearts despised. J. Bruce Ismay. It wasn’t long before Hearts began printing a cartoon depicting Ismay on Titanic, watching as lifeboats with women and children row to rescue ships in the cold, as Ismay watches with it captioned; “This is J. Brute Ismay” and “We respectfully suggest that the emblem of the White Star be changed to that of a yellow liver.”

Hearts Campaign of revenge on the Chairman of the White Star Line would only grow as an inquiry was launched into the disaster in order to find the causes that lead to such an incident happening in the first place. Within days, Senator William Alden Smith of Michigan set about setting up an inquiry into the incident involving the American owned, British-flagged liner. Similar actions took place across the Atlantic in England. With the survivors present in the states, America, and Smith’s efforts, the questioning began in the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel on 19 April. The hearings were relatively brief, however, due to the nature of the incident as it seemed all regulations and standard operating practices of the time.

In just 12 days of testimony from at least 70 or so witnesses, including from First Officer William Murdoch and Designer, Thomas Andrews, came to a close with Smith delivering his findings to the Senate in a report. Similarly, in Britain a commission would start at the end of April, and continue on until May 5. The British enquiry, headed by Lord Mersey, would hear from 100 witnesses, asked countles questions in regards to the operation of the ship and efforts by the crew in handling the evacuation. For the American Inquiry, Captain Edward Smith would be among those to testify upon Titanic’s arrival in Norfolk, Virginia on April 21.
Former passengers and crew during the American Inquiry
By the end, the investigations would come to similar conclusions. Fault lied partially on Captain Smith, for continuing to run at high speeds through dangerous waters, however this fault was followed by acknowledgment that his actions were in line with those of typical Captain’s of steamers during that day. Praise was in fact given to the master of Titanic, for his efforts following the collision and during the evacuation of the passengers of the ship and efforts in keeping Titanic afloat. Similarly, Thomas Andrews would testify and defend Captain Smith’s choices during the night of April 14, and added his own conclusions during the ship's journey to and from Halifax, Nova Scotia.

In the aftermath of the investigation's findings, several recommendations were made in order to deal with the aftermath of the disaster. These would be partially based on the observations and findings of Thomas Andrew’s and the rest of Titanic’s designers and engineers. The Board of Trade regulations, dating to 1894, were ultimately left unchanged, say for a push to include additional of lifeboats based around total passenger complement, rather than gross tonnage, in case of an emergency in order to allow more passengers to be moved off the ship when rescue arrived. Training of the crews and lifeboat drills were made mandatory on ships, whilst a round-the-cloak wireless watch was encouraged based on the testimony provided by Jack Phillips and Harold Bride. Finally, requirements for ships to have a double skin to prevent extensive flooding of watertight compartments and higher bulkheads was added.

The dangers of icebergs remained, thus the International Ice Patrol, headed by Revenue Cutter Service, began and would work to seek out, and report, icebergs. During the subsequent inquest into the disaster, particular criticism and press focus was leveled at J. Bruce Ismay. Under Hearst, the press focused on eyewitness accounts of Ismay pushing the Captain to speed the ship in order to surpass the previous maiden voyage time of Titanic’s sister ship, RMS Olympic. This was jumped on by the papers which began pushing the narrative of Ismay being the reason Titanic was put in such mortal danger to begin with. This became refuted though by others, including Captain Smith himself, who said the conversation had been taken out of context. Ultimately, Ismay was mostly praised for his efforts in assisting passengers during the evacuation and choosing to stay on the ship with Titanic’s crew as she steamed to Halifax, Nova Scotia.

Survivors, mostly amongst the wealthy though joined by some in second and third class, sued the White Star Line for losses of personal property, joined later by the families of the victims amongst Titanic’s crew who died during the attempt to save the ship. The total amount, originally $20M in damages, was reduced as the US Supreme Court ruled that the causes of the collision were unforeseen, and the total amount awarded was half that originally.
 
Last edited:
The luggage of some in 3rd, even 2nd, would have been ok since it was in cabins but the 1st would likely have been drowned Inc that shiny Renault car (likely in pieces and not complete like in the movie) so yeah White Star would compensate the richest to keep their patronage- though many would be singing their praises for getting them safe.

Hearst is a nasty piece of work; here with a surviving Captain and officers he is going to find a lot less angles of attack on Ismay and White Star. Captain Lord will escape the scapegoating he got OTL at least.

The industry are going to be taking a long hard look at their practises methinks.
 
Archibald and the Bull Moose (1912)
Archibald and the Bull Moose (1912)
800px-Archibald_Willingham_Butt.jpg
Theodore_Roosevelt_by_the_Pach_Bros.jpg

In May 28, 1912, RMS Titanic steamed up and prepared for her journey back, the last two months the ship spent in drydock repairing the damage caused to the ship's hull. For this, the Titanic was readied for the return voyage, with a number of her passengers reluctant to board whilst others eagerly did so for the vessel that had survived the ‘monstrous’ iceberg whilst out in the Atlantic swell. As she made ready to set off from pier 60, one of the White Star Line’s Piers for their ships. Her return voyage would last nine days, due to concerns the repairs done may still not be enough and the ship should go into dry dock at Harland and Wolf for a check up followed by modifications as recommended by the inquiry into Titanic’s collision with the berg. In July, RMS Titanic arrived to much fanfare as the families of those crew lost were among the crowd to welcome the ship back.

Her remaining journey saw the ship travel back to her the place of her birth in June, where the ship was laid up and for the next week, she would first be checked over from her journey back from the states, between June to July, 1912, the ship received a series of modifications alongside her older sister, Olympic and both ships were given a set of 32 lifeboats and extra set of davits along the boat deck to allow for lifeboats to be lowered away. A inner ‘skin’ was added along the forward watertight compartments, where the ship's boiler and engine rooms were located to ensure that in the worst case scenario, the ship would avoid an impact that could risk flooding these vital spaces.

In addition, the watertight compartments were extended upwards, though only four, including the one between the 6 boiler room and the forward compartments where the cargo holds were located. This was especially pushed by Chief Designer, Thomas Andrew’s who argued strongly for the change in order to ensure the Olympic-Class of ships could avoid a worst case scenario and flood with water overflowing into one compartment to the next. Finally, the ship's water pumps were improved to better allow water to be removed from the ship, this change based on the performance they had originally during the night of April 14-15, 1912.

Despite a strike from workers occurring, due to fears of the ships going down and the number of lifeboats suitable onboard, the ships returned to service in July and would take back her title of the largest ocean liner in the world, until the German Liner SS Imperator entered passenger service in June, 1913. As part of the marketing as the two ships entered service, the vessels were regarded as the “safest” and most well constructed ships in the world, highlighting the Night of April 15 and how there had been no loss of life from Titanic. This, alongside the Incident involving Olympic and HMS Hawke (a Royal Navy cruiser) would lead to the belief by some that the two ships were, indeed, “unsinkable” (though such a phrase was never officially used by the White Star Line or the crew of the trio).


As June moved into July, and finally August, the Presidential Election of 1912 was getting underway and witnessing for the first time a four-way race between candidates. Among these would be former President and Progressive, Theodore Roosevelt, Incumbent President and Conservative William Howard Taft, Democratic Candidate and Speaker of the House, Champ Clark, and Socialist Party candidate, Eugene V. Debs. The events which transpired previously would see a major split from both the Democratic and Republican Parties due to what many Liberals and Progressives believed was a severe lack of representation on each party's tickets. For the Republicans, the split came about following the change in direction of then President William Howard Taft, who originally ran as a continuation of former President Roosevelt and his fairly progressive agenda, to a more conservative and more business friendly direction.

During this time, Roosevelt began running for the Presidency separately after losing the Convention for the Republican nomination back in June to his former friend and successor, William Howard Taft. As the lines were drawn in the sand between the Progressive and Conservatives of the Republican Party, Roosevelt led his supporters out and would form the Progressive or “Bull Moose Party” in Chicago, Illinois where on August 5, 1912, Theodore Roosevelt and Governor Hiram Johnson of California were nominated easily.

The stacks were raised as previously, on June 25 and last until July 2, the Democratic National Convention began which saw a race between Governor Woodrow Wilson of New Jersey against Speaker of the House, Champ Clark of Missouri. Whilst other candidates existed, neither man was able to obtain the necessary delegates to win the nomination. As per the official two-thirds rule of the Democratic Party for the time, Clark was unable to take the nomination. Matters were not helped as Tammany Hall, a powerful but corrupt Democratic Political Machine in New York, offered their support. However, this would undoubtedly lead to the Progressives and Liberals (led by William Jennings Bryan) to turn against the speaker of the House.

Needing Progressive support to possibly secure the nomination, the Clark campaign began making moves behind the scenes to gain support from other candidates and supporters during the convention. Things came to a head once House Majority Leader Oscar Underwood of Alabama, in exchange for an endorsement and pledging his delegates to Clark, asked for a place on the ticket leading to the Clark campaign agreeing. Around this same time, Woodrow Wilson’s campaign had been in talks with Democratic bosses Roger Charles Sullivan of Illinois and Thomas Taggart of Indiana in which either offered to support the governor if Thomas R. Marshall would be the Governor’s running mate. Word would reach Wilson, however, that Clark had gained support from Oscar Underwood and losing faith of winning, opted instead to have his concession speech read before the final agreement could be reached.

Clark would follow this by revealing his support from Tammany Hall, which helped cement Clark’s place as the nominee for the nomination, but this action proved controversial with many and ultimately push former Democratic nominee, William Jennings Bryan, to denounce Clark as a candidate for Wall Street and ultimately encouraging his supporters not to back Clark.

As the Democratic Convention moved forward and the Party prepared to run for the White House, the Republican Party had already concluded their own Convention on June 22 with William Howard Taft and Vice Presidential Candidate, James S. Sherman, for the ticket. The Progressive had, in turn, held their own Convention on August 5, as mentioned above, where Roosevelt and Johnson would run for the Presidency.

As the election was underway, Roosevelt worked hard to gainer support for the Progressive Party and himself, working up and down the country giving speeches and denouncing Taft and Clark for their conservatism and the need for Roosevelt’s “New Nationalism” platform, including for social insurance programs, reduction to an eight-hour workday, and robust federal regulation of the economy. Clark campaigned on increased tariffs, limited regulation on business and more conservative policies. Taft would follow suit, running a subdued campaign based around “Progressive Conservatism” whilst Socialist Debs worked to gain support for his policies, and claimed all three candidates were financed by different capitalist trust and Roosevelt was a mere demagogue.

As campaign season continued forward, Roosevelt found himself making substantial gains and garnering support. On October 14, 1912, Roosevelt was joined by friend and former military aide, Archibald Butt. A military man known for both his hard work, organizational skills and thoughtfulness, had gone on to impress Roosevelt and the two men became close companions. After serving under both Roosevelt and later William Howard Taft, being close with both and fiercely loyal. Once the split occurred however, Butt had been left depressed and exhausted and had thus gone for a vacation with his housemate and friend, Francis Davis Millet, who the latter had requested on behalf of Butt in order to recuperate before the Presidential primaries.

Butt would end up returning after a six-week vacation in Europe on March 1, and would become a first-class passenger on the RMS Titanic on his return to the US. Boarding at Southampton, England on April 10, he was joined by Millet at Cherbourg France the same day. Upon arrival at New York following the Titanic’s collision with the iceberg, Butt would be labeled a hero for his efforts in helping passengers evacuate from the stricken ship and would be one of those to testify during the inquiries into the incident. Now, after a brief stay in the Empire state after briefly going to hospital following the incident, Butt would find himself still left split on who to back as the 1912 Presidential election continued. For the time being, however, Butt would opt for a brief stay at his home where he remained for sometime before leaving to meet with Roosevelt later before his trip to Milwaukee, Wisconsin whereby the two spent some time together and discussed what had happened between either of them up until that point.

As the two men made their way out from the Gilpatrick hotel, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, the two conversed about Archibald's fame following his journey on the RMS Titanic. “I assume you willingly choose to leave, yes?” The former President spoke, taking the time to watch his steps as he descended the stairs before turning to look at his friend. Archibald, in quiet contemplation, nodded before his eyes landed on the former President. “Yes. I argued to stay briefly, but was ushered off the ship nevertheless. Perhaps foolish of me, but there were still hundreds of women and children, many of whom were freezing in the cold.”

As the two approached the front entrance, Theodore halted alongside Archibald and followed suit as they could hear the crowd outside forming and cheering the former President on. “Well regardless of your actions, you’ve once more proven you are worthy of your rank and status, as well as my friendship, based on your actions that night.” After such praise, Archibald smiled in return before the two men shared a handshake before turning around and exiting. The crowd cheered, erupting in applause as Roosevelt stepped outside and stopped briefly to wave at his supporters and the general public. The presence of Archibald only served to galvanize the crowd, upon the latter man's actions and heroism during the Rescue of the RMS Titanic and her passengers.

The two men stepped into the car but not before Roosevelt stood up and greeted the crowd that surrounded them. As it seemed the former President was finally ready to set off, so it happened as Archibald caught sight of someone in the crowd. An unassuming man appeared a little disturbed, holding something out of view. As the crowd continued waving and cheering TR, so it happened. As the man unveiled a revolver, Archibald moved forward and grabbed hold of the former President as the would-be assassin fired. Instantly the crowd gasped and screamed whilst Elbert E. Martin, one of Roosevelt’s secretaries and an ex-football player, was quick to leap on Schrank and wrestle him to the ground and take his gun.

In the car still, Roosevelt had been forced down by Archibald, the latter of home clenched his shoulder blade tight. Cringing in discomfort and pain, Archibald struggled briefly and found a seat as Roosevelt came to and first turned to his friend, before addressing the crowd who were now demanding Schrank’s death. “Don’t hurt him! Let the Police get him!” The crowd, pleased to see their champion alive and well, did so and watched as a pair of Officers quickly approached and captured John Schrank, the assassin. Turning about face, Roosevelt quickly tended to his friend who continued to hold his shoulder in obvious discomfort, the bullet having struck his shoulder and possibly taken it out of commission. “Alright there, Archi?”

Archibald nodded, grinning a bit as he adjusted the way he was sitting down in order to be more comfortable. “Y-Yes. Though I’d rather have taken a bullet whilst on the field of battle, not on the campaign.” Immediately following, Schrank was taken away and would later end up institutionalized due to insanity. For TR and Archibald, the event concluded with Roosevelt continuing on to give his scheduled speech as intended, with Archibald not far behind still bleeding from the shoulder from the bullet wound. As part of his opening comments, he said;
Ladies and gentlemen, I don’t know whether you fully understand that I and my friend have been shot, but it takes more than that to kill a Bull Moose.”

Archibald was taken to hospital afterwards, but was found to have only suffered minor damage and was thus left to use a sling for sometime after the bullet's removal. Both Taft and Democratic nominee Clark suspended their campaigns as Roosevelt and Archibald recovered from what occurred, Taft especially out of respect for his dear friend after he learned of what occurred. The race for the White House went on, with continued support for the Bull Moose and his Progressive Party growing as many Progressive supporters flocked to his banner. After the disappointment following the Democratic Convention and Clark’s nomination, William Jennings Bryan was left with few alternatives and chose to endorse former President Roosevelt himself.​
 
Last edited:
Interesting chapter.

Now things start to deviate with Butt and other passengers now safely in America.

Also is it Gigantic or Britannic as the 3rd sister here? Snopes say there is true the 3rd ship would be Gigantic, and it does fit the naming scheme of the class…
 
1912-1913 (Brief Overview)
1912-1913
A Brief Overview

RMS Titanic would begin her service transporting passengers alongside her sister, Olympic, uninterrupted from July 1912 until the outbreak of War in 1914. Alongside the pair of ships, the White Star Line was graced by the entry of the third ship, RMS Gigantic. Replacing the “Big Four” for the route from Southampton, the four moved to the Liverpool route for the introduction of the Olympic class.

Titanic and Olympic would each cross the Atlantic side by side, often trading pleasant greetings in the form of ships horns and crowds of passengers watched on from either vessel as the other passed by. By 1913, RMS Gigantic joined and the White Star Line took the lead in the trans-Atlantic passenger service by virtue of the fact they were operating three of some of the largest ships afloat for a time.
Near-complete RMS Gigantic
RMS Aquitania during Construction

Despite an Era of good fortune for White Star, Cunard Line (the former's chief competition) would construct the RMS Aquitania, a distant “Cousin” of the lines successful RMS Lusitania and Mauritania.

Despite this period being a great success for White Star Line, competition remained from now just Cunard by other shipping giants across the world. Most especially from Germany and other European nations. Still, the Olympic class with their focus on Luxury over speed proved very popular with the general public, yet tragedy was to come in the form off one of the worst disasters in Canadian history.
1024px-RMS_Empress_of_Ireland_Colored_Picturee.png


(Note: I hope this TL is alright so far. Apologize if this wasn't as in depth as previous, but I have been debating if I should dive deeper into events besides the RMS Titanic herself or focus on the ship and her history whilst still highlighting other things going on. I may need some advice and/or opinion on this which would be helpful I'd say.)
 
Top